Article at a Glance:

  • American cheese is a creamy addition to various dishes, from burgers and sandwiches to grilled cheese and pizzas.
  • American cheese pairs well with varieties of seasonings, such as black pepper, garlic, paprika, and Cayenne pepper.

American cheese slices are a classic choice for burgers, sandwiches, and grilled cheese. American cheese is a timeless dairy delight, and the best thing about this cheese is it pairs so well with various seasonings. It is creamy, melts easily, and has a mild flavour, making it an idle pair on seasonings like black pepper, garlic, mustard powder, and many others. Nothing beats the lovely feeling of eating American cheese slices with various seasonings if you crave some delicious comfort food.

Here we list the top five seasonings that are perfect to pair with American cheese, along with some dishes that showcase the delicious flavour of the cheese.

Black pepper

Black pepper is a staple seasoning with boundless cooking options. The king of spices can season almost anything, from chicken, steak, prawns, and tofu to vegetables and paneer. Black pepper adds a touch of heat and depth to any dish, and when you pair it with American cheese slices, this is the cheesy combo of the finest level you should not miss. Black pepper with American cheese slices on a cheeseburger brings out the cheese’s creamy, nutty flavour and provides a satisfying contrast to the richness of cheese slices.

A classic cheeseburger with American cheese slices and seasoned black pepper is always a crowd-pleaser and a must-have for restaurants. You can also sprinkle black pepper on melted American cheese on top of baked potatoes or grilled cheese for a comforting snack.

Garlic

Garlic is another item that brings out the best in American cheese. Its sharp and savoury flavour adds depth and complexity to the cheese, making it a perfect pairing for garlic dishes, such as garlic bread and toast. Garlic bread with melted American cheese takes anyone on a sweeter, nuttier ride of flavour, and American slices’ creamy, salty taste is still there.

Raw garlic tastes spicy, making it a great choice for salads and meat paired with crushed cheese slices. Cooked garlic has a more sweet flavour profile and goes well with garlic bread and toast with melted cheese.

Paprika

Paprika with American cheese slices is a match made in heaven. Along with cheese slices, paprika’s fruity, slightly sweet flavour brightens almost any dish. You can use the powered red pepper as a garnish for egg and fish or as a marinade; paprika comes out as a showstopper. When paired with American cheese, paprika adds a smoky, slightly spicy and hot flavour that compliments the creaminess of cheese slices.

Add paprika to mac and cheese with American cheese for a delicious flavour twist. You can also sprinkle some paprika on grilled cheese; the result will be mouth-watering and pleasing.

Cayenne pepper

For those who enjoy spicy food, cayenne pepper is the perfect partner to pair with American cheese, like THINS burger slices and hi-melt cheese. Add cayenne pepper to a grilled cheese sandwich for a spicy twist on this classic comfort food. A grilled cheese sandwich is a popular lunch for kids, and the addition of some spic can be indulging for sandwich lovers. The niceness of heat from cayenne pepper complements the creamy, gooey hi-melt cheese slices, creating a rich and spicy flavour profile. The combination of creaminess and heat makes your sandwiches satisfying and flavourful.

A pinch of cayenne pepper can spice up your regular dishes, such as pizza, pasta, and egg. You can also use cayenne to prepare a spicy marinade by adding vinegar, garlic, and olive oil. The marinade will be a great addition to vegetables, chicken, and fish dishes. `

Italian seasoning

Italian seasoning is a versatile food that is a blend of herbs, including oregano, basil, thyme, rosemary, or coriander. It adds a delicious herbal flavour to any dish. Pairing Italian seasoning with cheese slices like hi-melt or THINS burger slices adds a savoury, satisfying flavour to various dishes.

Italian herb and American cheese quesadilla is a top-class dish for anyone who enjoys the creamy goodness of cheese with herbal flavour in their dishes. Cheeseburgers with American cheese and Italian seasoning is also a mouth-watering treat of complex flavours; strong earthy flavours and creamy, salty flavour to satisfy burger cravings.

Mustard powder

Muster powder blends well with American cheese slices, be it hi-melt cheese or THINS burger slices. The mustard powder adds a tangy, slightly bitter flavour that compliments the cheese’s creaminess and salty taste. You can use mustard powder with American cheese slices for delicious mustard and American cheese grilled sandwiches. The combination of creamy and tangy flavours in your sandwiches makes it a perfect easy lunch.

You can also use mustard powder with American cheese on mac and cheese to add a tangy twist to this classic comfort food. Or, sprinkle it on a baked potato with melted cheese for a quick, delicious, and satisfying snack. Mustard powder can also be used as seasonings on cheeseburgers.